How to Curate the Perfect Guest List for Your Next Supper Club

by David Litwak | 2025-09-25

There’s an art to hosting a memorable evening, and it starts well before the candles are lit or the table is set.

It starts with the guest list.

An elegant dinner party isn’t defined by decor alone; it’s shaped by tone, energy, and the conversations that unfold naturally. These moments don’t just happen; they’re curated with care.

Here’s how to shape your guest list with the same intention you give to the menu, the music, and the mood. Because when the right people come together, everything else falls into place.

Anchor the Evening in Emotion

Before you draft a guest list, pause and ask: “How do I want people to feel tonight?”

If the goal is warmth and comfort, invite the steady nurturers who make others feel at ease. If you want sparkle and laughter, include the natural storytellers. For a quieter, more reflective evening, bring in the guests who carry depth and thoughtfulness into every conversation.

Your list isn’t just about availability, it’s about shaping the emotional atmosphere you want the night to hold.

Cocktails in hand, guests mingled and connected before settling into an intimate dinner.
Cocktails in hand, guests mingled and connected before settling into an intimate dinner.

Keep the Guest List Small

When it comes to elegant hosting, less really can be more.

The ideal range for meaningful conversation is six to ten guests. That number keeps the table lively without feeling crowded. In smaller gatherings, every guest is part of the moment, no one fades into the background.

With fewer people, you can be more intentional. Menus feel personal, music feels selected for the mood, and seating feels curated rather than generic. A short guest list also creates a sense of occasion. When guests know they’re one of a select few, they arrive more engaged.

Little choices matter here. An odd number of guests helps break up cliques and sparks cross-conversation. Table shape plays a role too; round or square tables support inclusive dialogue, while long tables require extra thought so no one gets left out. Always walk through the seating plan ahead of time.

Intimate hosting leaves space for richer conversation and deeper connection. Guests walk away not just remembering the evening, but feeling like they were an essential part of it.

A custom Pepsi Zero Sugar cocktail, perfectly at home between vintage books and candlelight
A Pepsi Zero Sugar cocktail, perfectly at home between candlelight.

Seat with Intention

One of the simplest ways to elevate a gathering is to design for connection before anyone takes their seat.

Seating with intention turns a table from merely elegant into something meaningful. Place cards are optional, but the thought behind who sits where is what sets the tone.

Curate moments of discovery. Who has a story that another guest would love to hear? Seat the new perfume brand founder beside the collector of vintage fragrance bottles and let the dialogue unfold.

Think in values, not just interests. Two guests may work in completely different fields, but if they both care about craft, storytelling, or beauty, the spark is there.

Lean into contrast. A bold personality next to someone more reflective often creates a surprising balance that keeps the table alive.

Create bridges. If two guests don’t know each other but you sense they’ll connect, mention it in your welcome toast or share an anecdote to break the ice.

Use anchors. A warm conversationalist seated between quieter guests can help energy flow naturally across the table.

For an extra touch, handwritten place cards, slipped into linen napkins or tied to a sprig of rosemary, add formality without stiffness.

Thoughtful pairings are an invisible luxury. Guests may not pinpoint why the evening felt so fluid, but they’ll remember how comfortable and engaged they were.

When Rent the Runway brought their VIPs to Maxwell, the guest list was crafted with the same care as the menu. Media figures, fashion leaders, and entrepreneurs shared the table, while MSNBC’s Stephanie Ruhle joined the mix. Intentional seating, paired with a three-course chef-prepared meal, transformed the evening from a corporate dinner into something that felt like friends gathered for conversation, exactly what “pairing with purpose” is about.

A candlelit table set the stage for conversations for valentines at maxwell
A candlelit table set the stage for conversations for valentines at maxwell

Shape the Flow of the Table

A well-balanced table is intentionally more like a composition than a chart. Each seat contributes to the rhythm of the evening.

Think in terms of energy, not just names. When done with care, the flow feels natural, yet unmistakably harmonious.

Avoid couple clustering. Partners seated together often shrink into their own world. Keep them close enough for comfort, but apart enough to spark fresh conversations.

Blend familiarity with discovery. Seat a newcomer beside someone trusted so they feel anchored, yet still open to meeting others.

Manage volume. Two strong personalities side by side can dominate the table. Place them across or diagonally so their energy lifts the room without overpowering it.

Leave quiet spaces. A softer seat near someone warm and welcoming keeps the conversation moving without forcing it.

Embrace asymmetry. Perfect symmetry can feel stiff. A looser arrangement often creates the kind of flow that feels alive.

A balanced table doesn’t just look polished, it makes the night feel easy, connected, and memorable.

The Grand Room transformed into Rent the Runway’s private dining space, where every seat felt like a front row.
The Grand Room transformed into Rent the Runway’s private dining space, where every seat felt like a front row.

Finalize Your Venue

You may start with a rough idea of how many guests you want to invite, but the final count will depend on your venue’s capacity. Always ask for the comfortable maximum for each space you’ll use. This number is usually lower than the hard maximum, but it’s the one that determines whether your event feels pleasantly full or uncomfortably crowded.

Whether your event is large or small, your guest list has to stay under that capacity. Once the venue is booked, commit to the number. And don’t send out more Save the Dates than the space can realistically hold, as over-inviting will only cause problems later.

Pepsi chose Maxwell for their Supper Club because our spaces adapt to the events we host. Editors from Food & Wine and Bon Appétit dined across long tables while Chef Christina Miros reimagined familiar flavors. It was proof that when you finalize the right venue, it can become a true extension of your brand’s story.

Ready, Set, Host!

Once the invitations are out and the table is set, the magic of your dinner party comes down to the people and the connections you’ve curated. I

And if you’re looking for a setting where those moments naturally come to life, Maxwell is ready to host you. With rooms designed for intimacy, energy, and discovery, it’s the perfect backdrop for gatherings that feel unforgettable. Book a tour and see how your next dinner party can belong here.

Need help producing your event?

We built Maxwell Studios to provide full service, vertically integrated creative production, built from inside the very walls where our community has been coming alive since 2021.

CREATIVE DIRECTION

CHEF COLLABORATION

AV PRODUCTION

LOGISTICS

Address: 135 Watts, Floor 1, New York, NY, 10013

Walkable TO Westside Highway, One World Trade Center 9/11 Memorial, Duane Park, Battery Park

Nearby Neighborhoods

Tribeca, Financial District, SoHo, West Village, Greenwich Village, Nolita, Hudson Square

HOTELS NEARBY

Foquets, Greenwich Hotel, Arlo Soho, The Roxy, Soho Grand, The Frederick Hotel, Warren St Hotel, The Dominick, Hotel Hugo

LATE NIGHT spots nearby

Paul's Casablanca, Paul's Baby Grand, EAR Inn

Dinner spots nearby

The Odeon, Locanda Verde, Forgione, l'abeille, Wolfgang's Steakhouse, Yves, Mr Chows

Ready to join the family? We can’t wait to host you.

Ready to join the family? We can’t wait to host you.

Join our events list to get first access to availability, ideas from past celebrations, and exclusive Maxwell-hosted experiences.