Cafe Society

POLITICS

Fear of Heights

Progress would be easier if we could just get past the suspicion that someone might profit from it

By Jacob Mendel Brown | November 20 2026

In our recent midterm elections, Democrats swept the board. Candidates ranging from DSA lefties to Blue Dog moderates won all over the country. But most consequentially, the Republican Deep South firewall was broken with the election of a Democratic senator and governor in Texas. With its whopping 40 electoral votes in play for 2028, the Democratic Party has a new center of gravity.

On the Monday before his historic win of that Texas Senate seat, then-candidate, now senator-elect James Talarico appeared on the popular podcast Diary of a CEO. They discussed a range of topics, and the clippers had a field day, sending soundbites into the social media ether just in time for in-person voting.

One went particularly viral. Host Steven Bartlett asked for his views on “wokeism.” Talarico gave a beautiful and nuanced answer, pointing out that opposition to evils like racism unifies most Americans. The problem, he said, came with things like policing language.

“You’re no longer building a coalition to address those real problems that need addressing. Instead, you’re performing a kind of politics that’s about your own intellectual and emotional needs and not about actually making change.”

Talarico makes a simple but powerful distinction between a politics meant to deliver material benefits and a politics that turns inwards, that delivers psychological benefit to its participants. The result can be counterproductive. The dopamine hit from condemning a transgressor can be so great that we need another and another. Even if that means ignoring the solution, or worse yet, deepening the problem.

In their book Abundance, Ezra Klein and co-author Derek Thompson call this phenomenon “symbolically liberal, but operationally conservative.” To illustrate, they describe yard signs proclaiming solidarity with immigrants planted in front of multimillion-dollar San Francisco homes in single-family zoned neighborhoods whose NIMBY community boards rail against the building of new housing. Housing that any immigrant would need to have a hope of flourishing.

But this phenomenon isn’t simple hypocrisy. Across climate change, agriculture policy, and housing, we on the left, for all our good intentions, often allow ideology to swamp any real path to solutions. Put a corporate logo on a proposal, or have the woman delivering it arrive in a suit and a town car, and some of us suddenly develop an overly keen eye for everything that could go wrong. We wanna stick it to the man, whether that man’s bearing gifts or robbing us.

When it comes to housing, the fundamentals are pretty simple. There’s not enough of it; we need more of it. Demand is outstripping supply; so prices are high. Econ 101 stuff. And yet…

fear-of-heights-opening-portrait.png

Some of this begins with a perfectly reasonable suspicion. If a developer is proposing a new apartment tower, she expects to make a lot of money building it. That’s her motive. And that motive merits examination. It merits regulation. Indeed, a well-regulated market is part of what protects us from the robber barons. But somewhere along the way we began to treat that developer’s profit motive as a priori evidence against building the apartments at all. Indeed, for the anti-capitalist left, profit itself carries a moral stain. If the solution to a problem everyone agrees exists might mean someone—or worse yet, a big corporation—gets rich off the back of its solution, accepting that path can feel like surrendering to the enemy. Opposition offers a cleaner emotional bargain.

Stand up to the bad guys! Defend the good guys! If that means the people who need an apartment have to wait, well, that can be chalked up to nefarious corporate machinations, right?

Of course you don’t need to be a communist to resent your landlord. At least in New York, we all hate our landlords. This gives, say, DSA candidates a much larger audience than their ideology might garner alone. A housing shortage becomes a story with a face, a motive, someone to stand up to. The political and emotional temptation is to treat that shared antagonist as a policy argument.

Which brings us back to Talarico’s distinction. We can succeed at finding an enemy without solving any problems. Once those two achievements become muddled, we start keeping a peculiar set of accounts. Every defeat inflicted on a landlord goes in the ledger, while the cost of every apartment never built, or applicant never approved—well, that barely registers.

Earlier this year, on April 15th, Mayor Mamdani celebrated Tax Day by standing outside 220 Central Park South to promote his proposed pied-à-terre tax. He literally put a face to the housing crisis: Ken Griffin, the CEO of Citadel, who lived in that very building. Back in 2019, he’d purchased his cute little flat there for $238 million. Yikes.

Griffin was not a fan of the doxxing the mayor gave him. And the war of words between the two became vitriolic. Griffin threatened to leave the city, to move jobs to Miami. In reality, it's unclear if jobs moved and things have largely calmed down. And let’s be clear. There’s nothing wrong with taxing mansions, and there’s nothing wrong with taxing pieds-à-terre.

However, the tenor of Mamdani's announcement was punitive. Buyers of these condos were being punished for buying apartments in a city facing a housing crisis, for driving up prices, for being bad guys.

But pieds-à-terre are by definition good for a city. They generate outsized tax revenue. And their part-time inhabitants take up precious few city resources. The optimal policy around their taxation should be one that maximizes city property tax revenue, which goes straight to funding the city’s social programs.

mamdani-griffin-editorial.png
Mayor Mamdani and Citadel CEO Ken Griffin face off.

It felt good for everyone to rail against Ken Griffin and his ilk. But whether Griffin deserved our resentment tells us little about how to design a tax. The test should be what it delivers for New Yorkers, not how satisfying it is to watch him pay.

Many similarly emotionally motivated housing policies have the same problem. Instead of pumping up supply through building new units, for years and years, most New York housing policy has been focused on tenant protection.

Not that long ago, a young person in New York faced lower rents. They also had myriad options to qualify for an apartment with less than perfect income and rent history. You could save up a little extra and pre-pay a few months' rent. That’s now banned by the city. You could pay first and last month’s rent as security deposit, instead of just first month’s. That too is banned. Most of the tools previously available to a renter to persuade a reluctant landlord to approve a lease have been taken away.

Similarly, it has become increasingly difficult for landlords to evict non-paying tenants. Tenants absolutely need protection from arbitrary eviction. Good Cause eviction laws, while debated by the real estate industry, attempt to address stability by limiting rent hikes in a given year. However, all the various protections that have been implemented in the New York rental system mean that an eviction proceeding can now take, according to a recent New York Housing Conference report, more than a year in some cases. There are various adjournments, disputes over proper notice, litigation over specifics of the rent owed, and appeals and stays. An error in the landlord’s application can mean resetting the clock. Each month is a month of lost rental income. And on top of that, there are legal fees and possible property damage that will require substantial repair.

These safeguards are meant to protect current renters, but many have been enacted without an examination of their impact on applicants, on people who need homes. Ironically, corporate landlords with deep pockets are more able to weather the storm of a long eviction. For smaller mom-and-pop landlords—the sort we all prefer and certainly the sort preferred by more anti-capitalist New Yorkers—a single drawn-out eviction can be financially calamitous.

Faced with those risks, landlords have a reason to demand higher application standards. Escalating protections for the tenant already inside can become barriers for the applicants outside—especially the applicant with shaky credit, irregular income, or no wealthy guarantor.

All of this is made worse by the lack of supply, something that is rarely if ever contemplated in liberal New York politics. The city does not and will likely never have the budget to build the hundreds of thousands of needed new apartments in the city. The fact that the people moving to New York are affluent and often looking for more luxurious housing makes the calculus that much more difficult. For a politics organized around suspicion of profit, it's an uncomfortable possibility: a developer can make a fortune and still leave a neighborhood better housed. That possibility should be a win-win for a politics concerned with material outcomes. Instead, the profit is the conspicuous deal killer.

In his critique of the “precautionary principle,” legal scholar Cass Sunstein examines the risk of inaction and how often it is ignored in favor of the shinier risk of action. Policy solutions with their identifiable owners and imaginable failures get scrutinized. The impact from inaction—be it shortage, pollution, or simply living in the status quo—gets glossed over.

Housing is not the only arena where this issue rears its head. Climate change is arguably the greatest existential threat humanity has ever faced. Fossil fuel burning could quite literally lead to human extinction. That corporations are required to prospect, extract, and distribute those carbon-laden fuels aligns this issue perfectly with the anti-capitalist left’s fight against its preferred villain. But short of turning in our car keys and turning off our heat and air conditioning, anti-capitalist revolt is not a real solution.

Solar and wind power, while still corporately developed, possess a veneer of green respectability. But the cost in scaling them to actually replace fossil fuels is hard to surmount.

Not so for nuclear power. A pellet of nuclear fuel the size of a gummy bear can replace a ton of coal. It requires many tens of thousands of acres of solar farm to take the place of a single small nuclear reactor. When it comes to nuclear waste, the public generally has little sense of how startlingly small the scale of the problem is. In 2022, the Department of Energy estimated that ALL of the spent fuel produced by American reactors since the 1950s could be stored in a warehouse with the footprint of a single football field. And that's with old reactors. Modern reactors, which repeatedly recycle their fuel, would reduce that to a tenth of a football field.

The safety of reactors is of course the underlying fear, and the real juice behind the villainizing of the industry’s corporate owners. But again, the sense of scale is completely distorted. In short, the risk from nuclear is a lot like the risk from flying an airplane. The occasional accident is horrifying, and yet flying is tremendously safer than driving. Per terawatt-hour, coal power kills almost 25 people. Oil kills 18 people. For wind and solar it's .04 and .02—and nuclear is right in the middle at .03. Like airplane crashes, nuclear accidents have inflicted real suffering. But measured against the unimaginable amount of electricity each plant produces, it's as safe or safer than wind or solar. We could be making actual progress toward ending and reversing climate change right now. Instead we rail against fossil fuels, while blasting our AC and drinking lattes through paper straws.

Another example is agricultural policy. In the EU, every nation has mandates on the sale of organically farmed produce. The Monsantos of the world find few customers there. But is this policy doing anything besides raising the cost of food by forcing everyone to buy luxury veg?

Organic farming certainly looks cleaner when we measure impact by the acre. But an acre is not a meal. If that acre produces less food, then it follows more acres are needed to feed the same number of people. Meta-analyses of studies tend to find that any per-acre advantages disappear and even reverse when measured against quantity of food produced—remember that organic fertilizers and pesticides are gentler but not harmless. And that doesn’t even take into account water use which skyrockets with organic farming.

We could be making actual progress toward ending and reversing climate change right now. Instead we rail against fossil fuels, while blasting our AC and drinking lattes through paper straws.

Worse yet, Europe’s aversion to GMO crops can impact food security in poorer nations that rely on Europe as an export market. Research has clearly documented this pressure on the planting decisions farmers in Africa are forced to make. For instance, a 2017 study examined the impact of a one-year delay in approval of an insect-resistant cowpea in Nigeria. The financial cost to farmers there was in the tens of millions. Deaths in the thousands. Inaction when it comes to adoption of new crops pleases the sensibilities of European customers. But it is not free.

I’m the first to admit I love an expensive organic tomato from my local farmers market; I love a solar panel on a roof. There’s nothing wrong with wanting things to taste good, to feel good, including our politics. And there’s something very wrong with letting the billionaire class run roughshod over our own self-interest, in letting them mortgage our collective future for a profit. But just as we question those profit-driven interests, we should question those who play on our emotions to gain power. And we should question the cost of doing nothing. Good intentions should make us more curious about what works, and more willing to change our minds when something doesn't.

The current moment is, unexpectedly, one of hope. Hope can lead to progress, or it can lead to disappointment. The trick is embracing progress no matter who it arrives from. Let’s regulate that developer. Let’s tax those profits. But let’s also get that apartment built. When somewhere, someone gets handed a set of keys, we should be able to feel it as a victory.